The Man-Made “Sunnah”
How Mainstream Sunni Islam Deviated from Allah’s Way
Islam, as revealed in the Qurʾān, is crystal clear about its authority and guidance. God’s message, embodied in the Qurʾān, is complete, perfect, and fully detailed:
“We have, without doubt, sent down the Reminder; and We will assuredly preserve it.” (15:9)
“Do they not consider the Qurʾān carefully? Had it been from any other than Allah, they would surely have found therein much contradiction.” (4:82)
Yet today, the religion most Muslims call “Islam” — mainstream Sunni Islam — bears little resemblance to the way the Qurʾān itself defines guidance. This divergence stems largely from a single historical development: the creation of the so-called Sunnah of the Prophet as a separate, quasi-divine authority alongside the Qurʾān.
The Qurʾān speaks of sunnat Allāh — the “way” or “law” of God — as the ultimate standard of guidance, judgment, and morality. The Qurʾān never once mentions a “Sunnah of Muhammad” as a binding, independent source. Yet modern Sunni Islam has elevated human-collected traditions — hadith — into a source of law and authority that often overrides the Qurʾān itself. To understand this, we need to examine the historical evolution of the Sunnah.
1. The Qurʾānic Concept of Sunnah
The word sunnah in the Qurʾān always refers to Allah’s way, not Muhammad’s personal practices:
“That was the Sunnah of Allah among those who passed before, and you will never find any change in the Sunnah of Allah.” (33:62)
“And We did not punish them except for what they earned.” (35:43)
“And We have never changed the Sunnah of Allah.” (48:23)
Linguistically, sunnah means a path, way, or example. The Qurʾān repeatedly uses it to describe God’s unchanging pattern in history, whether in dealing with nations, punishing wrongdoers, or guiding believers. There is no Qurʾānic basis for the idea of a separate “Sunnah of the Prophet”; that concept is a human invention.
The Qurʾān commands obedience to the Prophet, but in a precise sense:
“Whoever obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah.” (4:80)
“Take what the Messenger gives you and abstain from what he forbids you.” (59:7)
Notice the logic: obedience to Muhammad is obedience to God — because Muhammad is acting strictly within God’s revelation. The Qurʾān never gives the Prophet authority apart from God. He is a human messenger, tasked with conveying and living the Qurʾān, not inventing law.
This distinction is critical. Obeying Muhammad does not mean following a human-devised system of rituals, jurisprudence, or traditions that later generations attributed to him. Obedience is valid only to the extent that he follows Allah’s revelation. Any deviation is not binding.
2. The Prophet’s Life: Obedience, Not Innovation
The Qurʾān portrays Muhammad as the ultimate example of submission to God:
“Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day.” (33:21)
The Prophet’s life was a model of faithfulness to Allah’s commands. He did not act independently. Every judgment, every instruction, every personal action had to align with God’s revelation (7:203; 46:9; 53:3–4). In Qurʾānic terms, he is an exemplar of obedience to Allah, not an autonomous lawgiver.
Thus, when the Qurʾān commands Muslims to follow Muhammad, it is clear that the measure of his authority is his adherence to God’s guidance. Obedience to the Prophet outside that framework — for example, following a ritual or ruling that contradicts the Qurʾān — is not obedience at all.
3. The Oral Period After the Prophet’s Death (632–700 CE)
After Muhammad’s death, the Qurʾān was compiled, preserved, and transmitted, but the Prophet’s sayings and practices were not systematized. Early Muslims naturally recalled how he handled specific issues, especially in prayer, law, and social matters. These recollections were oral, localized, and inconsistent.
At this point, there was no formal “Sunnah of the Prophet” as an independent source of law. What people remembered was simply how the Prophet exemplified the Qurʾān, nothing more. Any local variations were based on memory, personal interpretation, and culture.
4. The Hadith Movement (8th–9th Century CE)
As Islam spread across the Middle East, North Africa, and Asia, questions of law and practice multiplied. Scholars began to collect, verify, and systematize reports about the Prophet’s words and deeds.
Figures like al-Bukhārī and Muslim ibn al-Ḥajjāj compiled thousands of hadith, grading them for authenticity.
This process gave birth to the formal concept of the Prophet’s Sunnah: a separate, quasi-divine body of law that Muslims were obligated to follow alongside the Qurʾān.
Here, human memory and scholarly judgment began to stand in for revelation, creating a system that claimed divine authority but was entirely human in origin.
The Qurʾān does not authorize this. It emphasizes that the Prophet’s authority derives solely from obedience to God, not humanly constructed reports:
“Say: I do not tell you that I possess the treasures of Allah or that I know the unseen.” (6:50)
5. Legal Formalization and the Sunni Schools (9th–10th Century CE)
By the time of al-Shāfiʿī (d. 820 CE), Sunni scholars had codified Islamic law around four sources:
The Qurʾān
The Sunnah (as recorded in hadith)
Consensus (ijmāʿ)
Analogy (qiyās)
Al-Shāfiʿī argued that obeying the Prophet required accepting the Sunnah as a source of divine guidance. This elevated humanly collected reports to a near-revelatory status, creating a system that went far beyond the Qurʾān itself.
What had begun as a faithful effort to preserve the Prophet’s teachings became a man-made framework, institutionalized over centuries, which now defines “mainstream Sunni Islam.”
6. The Problem with the Man-Made Sunnah
The consequences of this historical development are profound:
Deviation from the Qurʾān: Many hadith and juristic rulings contradict the Qurʾān’s clear commands. The Qurʾān emphasizes mercy, justice, and God’s unity (tawḥīd), yet later Sunnī jurisprudence often prioritizes ritualistic detail and human interpretation over divine guidance.
Authority Shift: Obedience shifted from Allah (via His Qurʾān) to human scholars and traditions. Muslims are often taught to accept rulings because “the Prophet said so”, without verifying alignment with the Qurʾān.
Sectarian Division: The elevation of man-made Sunnah created rigid schools and sects. Whereas the Qurʾān warns against division (30:32), Sunni Islam became a collection of legal, theological, and ritual hierarchies built around human-authored hadith.
7. Return to Qurʾān-Centric Islam
A Qurʾān-only perspective reclaims the original vision:
The only Sunnah is the Sunnah of Allah, expressed in the Qurʾān.
The Prophet is honored as the perfect exemplar of submission, but obeyed only in so far as he follows revelation.
Any practice, ruling, or tradition that contradicts the Qurʾān is not binding.
This framework preserves tawḥīd (monotheism) and ensures that authority rests with God, not human scholars or collections. It also aligns with the Qurʾānic principle that obeying the Messenger is obeying Allah, and obedience outside revelation is meaningless.
8. Conclusion: How Mainstream Sunni Islam Misplaced Authority
The mainstream Sunni system, while claiming continuity with the Prophet, is historically a human construction. It arose from:
Oral recollections of the Prophet’s actions
Systematic collection of hadith centuries later
Elevation of those hadith to near-revelatory authority
Legal codification and institutionalization into Sunni schools
None of this contradicts the Prophet’s own role as a messenger of Allah — but it does shift authority from Allah’s Qurʾān to human interpretation, creating a “man-made Sunnah” that the Qurʾān never authorized.
A return to Qurʾān-centric Islam means:
Recognizing that obedience to Muhammad is obedience to Allah alone.
Rejecting any tradition or law that contradicts Qurʾānic guidance.
Honoring the Prophet as a perfect example of submission, not as an independent lawgiver.
In other words, true Islam is following the Sunnah of Allah, as manifested in the Qurʾān, through the life of the Prophet, not following centuries of human elaboration called “the Sunnah of Muhammad.”
This is the reality: the religion most Muslims practice today — mainstream Sunni Islam — is not the Sunnah of Allah; it is a man-made structure built upon human interpretations, recollections, and institutional traditions. Returning to Qurʾānic primacy is not a rejection of the Prophet — it is honoring him in the only way the Qurʾān commands: as the faithful servant and perfect exemplar of Allah’s way.
9. Qurʾānic Evidence for Following Allah Alone Through the Prophet
The Qurʾān repeatedly emphasizes that authority lies with Allah, and that the Prophet’s role is to convey and embody Allah’s guidance, not to legislate independently. Below is a categorized list of key verses:
A. Obedience to Allah and the Messenger
These verses make it clear that obedience to the Prophet is conditional on his alignment with Allah:
4:80 – “Whoever obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah; but if they turn away, We have not sent you over them as a keeper.”
Highlights that obedience is ultimately to Allah; the Prophet’s authority is derivative.
59:7 – “Take what the Messenger gives you and abstain from what he forbids you…”
Obedience is framed as following the Messenger only insofar as it aligns with revelation.
3:31 – “Say: If you love Allah, then follow me; Allah will love you and forgive you your sins.”
Following the Prophet is a means to obey Allah, not an independent path.
B. The Prophet Acts Only by Revelation
The Qurʾān repeatedly emphasizes that Muhammad does not act independently:
7:203 – “And when you do not bring them a sign, they say, ‘Why have you not invented it?’ Say: I follow only what is revealed to me from my Lord.”
46:9 – “Say: I am not an innovator among the messengers; I follow only what is revealed to me.”
53:3–4 – “Nor does he speak from desire; it is nothing but revelation revealed.”
These verses underscore that the Prophet’s entire mission is submission to Allah’s way — sunnat Allāh — and nothing more.
C. Allah’s Sunnah is Unchanging
33:62 – “That was the Sunnah of Allah among those who passed before; you will never find any change in the Sunnah of Allah.”
35:43 – “And We did not punish them except for what they earned.”
48:23 – “And We have never changed the Sunnah of Allah.”
These passages clarify that the Qur’ān alone contains the immutable guidance for humanity. Any human attempt to add, modify, or codify law outside the Qurʾān is an innovation (bidʿah).
D. The Prophet as an Example, Not Legislator
33:21 – “Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day.”
The Prophet is a model of following Allah’s way, not the source of a separate Sunnah.
5:48 – “To you We have revealed the Book with truth, confirming what was before it. Judge between them by what Allah has revealed…”
The Prophet’s judgments must reflect divine revelation; human reasoning cannot replace God’s law.
E. Warning Against Following Anything That Contradicts Allah
6:114 – “Shall I seek other than Allah for judgment while He is the one who revealed to you the Book fully detailed?”
Muslims are commanded to judge by the Qur’ān alone.
18:26 – “Allah judges with truth; and those you call upon besides Him cannot judge anything.”
Only God’s law — not human collections of the Prophet’s sayings — has ultimate authority.
F. Summary of Qurʾānic Principle
From these verses, a Qurʾān-centric framework emerges:
The Prophet is the perfect exemplar of obedience to Allah.
Obedience to the Prophet is obedience to God; any deviation is not binding.
The Sunnah of Allah, expressed in the Qurʾān, is immutable and fully sufficient.
Human traditions, hadith, or juristic rulings cannot supersede or contradict Allah’s guidance.
10. Implication for Mainstream Sunni Islam
With this Qurʾānic evidence, it becomes clear why the mainstream Sunni system — with its codified hadith collections, legal schools, and rituals based on a “Prophet’s Sunnah” — is historically man-made:
It elevates human memory and scholarship to a quasi-divine authority.
It allows rulings and practices that sometimes contradict the Qurʾān.
It obscures the Qurʾān’s centrality as the only binding Sunnah of Allah.
Returning to Qurʾān-centric Islam restores the original vision: the Prophet as a faithful messenger and exemplar, and the Qurʾān as the only immutable source of guidance, the only expression of sunnat Allāh.
No comments:
Post a Comment