Mauao Man

Islamic Education in New Zealand:

Schools, Curriculum, and Controversies

Balancing Faith and Secular Standards in the Classroom

Introduction: Faith Meets Education

Islamic education in New Zealand is a rapidly growing sector, reflecting the nation’s increasing Muslim population. For Muslim parents, Islamic schools offer a place where their children can learn in an environment that respects their faith. But these schools also raise important questions: How do they balance Islamic values with New Zealand’s secular education standards? Are they providing critical thinking skills, or are they promoting religious dogma?

This post explores the rise of Islamic schools in New Zealand, the challenges they face, and the controversies they generate.

1. The Growth of Islamic Schools in New Zealand

1. The First Islamic Schools: Al-Madinah School and Zayed College for Girls

Al-Madinah School (Auckland): Established in 1992, Al-Madinah School is New Zealand’s first Islamic school. It offers education from primary to secondary levels and is co-educational.
Zayed College for Girls (Auckland): Opened in 2001, Zayed College is a secondary school exclusively for girls, focusing on Islamic education alongside New Zealand’s standard curriculum.
Other Islamic Schools: There are several other Islamic schools in New Zealand, including:
- Iqra Elementary School (Auckland)
- Al-Noor Islamic School (Christchurch)
- Al-Hikmah School (Hamilton)

2. The Rise of Islamic Education

The growth of these schools reflects the increasing Muslim population in New Zealand, which reached approximately 57,276 Muslims in the 2018 Census.
Many Muslim parents choose Islamic schools because they provide a safe space for their children to learn without facing discrimination or peer pressure to abandon Islamic values.
Islamic schools also offer an environment where Muslim students can pray, wear the hijab, and celebrate Islamic holidays without fear of exclusion.

2. What Makes an Islamic School “Islamic”?

1. A Dual Curriculum: Islamic Studies and Secular Subjects

Islamic schools in New Zealand must teach the New Zealand Curriculum, which includes subjects like English, Mathematics, Science, Social Studies, and Physical Education.
In addition, they offer Islamic Studies, which cover:
- Quranic Studies: Learning to read, recite, and memorize the Quran.
- Islamic Theology (Aqidah): Teaching the core beliefs of Islam.
- Islamic History: Stories of the prophets, Islamic civilization, and the life of Muhammad.
- Fiqh (Islamic Law): Basic teachings on Islamic practices, such as prayer, fasting, and charity.
Arabic is also taught as a language, providing students with the ability to read and understand the Quran.

2. Daily Religious Practices

Islamic schools provide facilities for daily prayers (Salah), with students participating in group prayers during school hours.
Islamic holidays such as Eid al-Fitr and Eid al-Adha are celebrated as part of the school calendar.
Islamic values, including modesty, respect for elders, and ethical behavior, are emphasized throughout the school day.

3. Gender Segregation: Separate Spaces for Boys and Girls

Some Islamic schools, like Zayed College for Girls, are single-gender schools, focusing on girls' education in an Islamic environment.
Co-educational Islamic schools may practice gender segregation in certain areas, such as prayer spaces or sports.
Supporters argue that this protects students' modesty, while critics see it as promoting outdated gender roles.

3. The Benefits of Islamic Schools

1. A Safe Space for Muslim Students

Islamic schools provide a sense of belonging for Muslim students who may feel isolated in secular schools.
Students can wear the hijab, pray, and openly practice their faith without fear of discrimination.
Teachers often serve as role models, combining professional qualifications with a strong understanding of Islamic values.

2. Academic Excellence

Many Islamic schools in New Zealand have a strong academic record, with high pass rates in NCEA (National Certificate of Educational Achievement) exams.
Some students go on to pursue higher education in fields like medicine, law, engineering, and education.
Schools like Al-Madinah and Zayed College regularly produce top-performing students.

3. Character Development and Moral Education

Islamic schools place a strong emphasis on ethical behavior, teaching students the importance of honesty, respect, charity, and social responsibility.
Many parents see this moral education as equally important as academic success.

4. The Controversies: Balancing Faith and Critical Thinking

1. Concerns About Indoctrination

Critics argue that Islamic schools may promote religious dogma rather than encouraging critical thinking.
Some fear that teaching Islamic theology alongside secular subjects may create a conflict between faith and reason.
In some cases, former students have reported feeling pressured to conform to conservative interpretations of Islam.

2. Gender Segregation and Gender Roles

Gender segregation in Islamic schools is controversial, with some seeing it as a form of gender discrimination.
Critics argue that it reinforces traditional gender roles and prevents boys and girls from learning to interact as equals.
Supporters argue that it protects modesty and creates a focused learning environment.

3. Questioning the Curriculum: Science vs. Religion

Some Islamic schools have been criticized for teaching creationism instead of evolution in science classes.
There are concerns that religious education may discourage students from questioning religious teachings, limiting critical thinking skills.
Supporters argue that students are taught about evolution as part of the New Zealand Curriculum but are also given an Islamic perspective.

4. The Role of FIANZ: Who Oversees Islamic Education?

FIANZ (Federation of Islamic Associations of New Zealand) provides guidance on Islamic education, but it does not directly control Islamic schools.
Each school has its own board of trustees, which determines its policies, curriculum, and staff.
Critics argue that this can lead to inconsistent standards between schools.

5. Stories from Inside: Voices of Students and Teachers

1. Aisha’s Story: Balancing Two Worlds

Aisha, a former student of Zayed College for Girls, describes how the school gave her a strong foundation in her faith but left her feeling unprepared for university life, where she encountered conflicting ideas.

2. Bilal’s Journey: From Student to Teacher

Bilal, a graduate of Al-Madinah School, became a teacher there, seeing it as a way to give back to his community.
He emphasizes the importance of encouraging students to ask questions and think critically about their faith.

3. Sara’s Experience: Rejecting Gender Stereotypes

Sara, a student at an Islamic school, challenged the school's policy of gender segregation, arguing that boys and girls should learn to respect each other as equals.
Her activism led to a review of the school’s policies.

6. The Future of Islamic Education in New Zealand

1. Balancing Faith and Critical Thinking

Islamic schools will need to ensure that they promote not just religious knowledge but also critical thinking, scientific understanding, and cultural awareness.

2. Greater Transparency and Oversight

Calls for better oversight of Islamic schools to ensure that they meet New Zealand’s educational standards.
Discussions around whether FIANZ should play a greater role in setting standards for Islamic education.

3. New Schools and Expanding Access

As the Muslim population grows, demand for Islamic education is likely to increase.
New Islamic schools may open in cities like Wellington, Hamilton, and Christchurch.

Conclusion: Islamic Education in New Zealand — Faith, Learning, and Controversy

Islamic schools in New Zealand are more than just places of learning — they are spaces where young Muslims can explore their faith, build their identity, and prepare for the future. But they are also places where complex questions must be answered: How can faith and critical thinking coexist? Where should the line be drawn between religious values and New Zealand’s secular standards?

For Muslim parents, these schools offer a safe space for their children. For critics, they raise concerns about segregation, indoctrination, and a lack of transparency. But one thing is clear — as New Zealand’s Muslim community grows, the role of Islamic education will continue to be a topic of debate.

The Changing Face of Islam in New Zealand: From Immigrants to Native Kiwis
Muslim Women in New Zealand: Voices Behind the Veil
Islam and Māori Culture: A Unique Intersection
The Christchurch Effect: How a Tragedy Changed the Perception of Islam in New Zealand
Islam: What It Really Teaches — And What It Means for New Zealand

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

About the Author

Mauao Man is a blog created by a New Zealand writer who believes in following the evidence wherever it leads. From history and religion to culture and society, Mauao Man takes a clear, critical, and honest approach — challenging ideas without attacking people. Whether exploring the history of Islam in New Zealand, the complexities of faith, or the contradictions in belief systems, this blog is about asking the hard questions and uncovering the truth.

If you value clarity over comfort and truth over tradition, you’re in the right place.