Mauao Man

Islam’s Three Faces: From Peaceful Preacher to Conquering Warlord

How Muhammad’s Message Changed with Power — And Why It Still Matters Today

Introduction: One Religion, Three Masks — How Islam’s Message Changed with Power

Islam is often presented as a single, unchanging faith — a timeless message of peace and spirituality. But history tells a very different story. Muhammad’s message was not always one of peace, nor was it always about personal faith. In fact, the teachings of Islam shifted dramatically depending on Muhammad’s circumstances — from a persecuted preacher in Mecca to a powerful warlord in Medina.

These changes were not random. They were part of a strategic evolution — a three-stage model that has shaped Islamic history for over 1,400 years. From the peaceful, patient beginnings in Mecca to the aggressive, dominant stance in Medina, Islam has always adapted to its situation.

This post exposes the Three Faces of Islam — how the message shifts from peaceful coexistence to militant supremacy as Muslim power grows. This is not just a historical observation. It is a blueprint for Islamic expansion, confirmed by classical Islamic scholars and echoed in modern Islamic movements worldwide.

If you’ve ever wondered why Islam can seem peaceful in one place and aggressive in another, this post will reveal the answer. Understanding the Three Faces of Islam is the key to understanding its true nature.

1. Stage One: Weakness — The Mecca Period (610–622 AD)

1. A Religion of Peace and Patience

Context: Muhammad’s early years in Mecca, where he and his followers were a small, persecuted minority.
Message: Peace, tolerance, patience, and forgiveness.
Quranic Verses:
- “There is no compulsion in religion.” (Quran 2:256)
- “To you be your religion, and to me be mine.” (Quran 109:6)
- “Forgive them and overlook.” (Quran 2:109)

2. The Strategy of Survival

Muhammad’s focus was on attracting followers without provoking the powerful Quraysh tribe.
Islam was presented as a purely spiritual message with no political ambitions.
The Quranic message emphasized personal faith, morality, and patience in the face of persecution.

3. Scholarly Confirmation: Ibn Kathir and Al-Tabari

Ibn Kathir: “The verse ‘There is no compulsion in religion’ (Quran 2:256) was revealed when Muslims were weak and in a position of vulnerability.”
Al-Tabari: “In Mecca, the Prophet was commanded to be patient, to overlook, and to avoid confrontation.”

4. Historical Example: The Year of Sorrow (619 AD)

Muhammad’s uncle Abu Talib and his wife Khadijah died, leaving him without protection.
Facing persecution, Muhammad continued to preach peace, emphasizing personal faith.
His followers were tortured, but they were commanded to endure with patience.

2. Stage Two: Strength — The Medina Period (622–630 AD)

1. From Persecution to Power

Context: Muhammad and his followers migrated to Medina, where they gained political and military power.
Message: Defensive fighting, assertiveness, and establishing an Islamic community.
Quranic Verses:
- “Permission to fight is given to those who are wronged.” (Quran 22:39)
- “Fight in the way of Allah those who fight you.” (Quran 2:190)
- “But if they cease, let there be no hostility.” (Quran 2:193)

2. The Strategy of Expansion

In Medina, Muhammad became both a religious leader and a political ruler.
His focus shifted from personal faith to community governance and military strategy.
Treaties were signed, alliances were formed, and defensive battles were fought.

3. Scholarly Confirmation: Ibn Qayyim and Al-Qurtubi

Ibn Qayyim: “The Prophet was first commanded to be patient and to avoid conflict… then he was permitted to fight in self-defense, and finally he was commanded to fight against all who opposed Islam.”
Al-Qurtubi: “The verse ‘Fight those who do not believe…’ (Quran 9:29) is a command for Muslims to establish dominance once they have the strength.”

4. Historical Example: The Battle of Badr (624 AD)

Muhammad led his followers in a surprise attack on a Quraysh caravan, achieving a decisive victory.
This was the first time Muslims engaged in organized combat, marking the beginning of Islam’s military expansion.
After the victory, the Quranic message became more assertive, emphasizing the right to fight and defend the faith.

3. Stage Three: Dominance — The Conquest Period (630–632 AD)

1. The Message of Supremacy

Context: After the conquest of Mecca, Muhammad became the undisputed ruler of Arabia.
Message: Aggressive expansion, forced conversion, and the imposition of Sharia.
Quranic Verses:
- “Fight those who do not believe in Allah.” (Quran 9:29)
- “When the sacred months have passed, kill the polytheists wherever you find them.” (Quran 9:5)
- “The Prophet is a witness, a bearer of good news, and a warner.” (Quran 48:8)

2. The Strategy of Domination

Islam became a complete political and legal system.
Non-Muslims were forced to submit to Muslim rule or face military conquest.
Apostates (those who left Islam) were to be killed, and criticism of Muhammad was punishable by death.
Sharia (Islamic law) was imposed as the governing system for all.

3. Scholarly Confirmation: Ibn Kathir and Al-Jalalayn

Ibn Kathir: “The verse of the sword (9:5) abrogated every agreement of peace between the Prophet and any idolater.”
Al-Jalalayn: “This verse (9:5) abrogated any verse of peace.”

4. Historical Example: The Conquest of Mecca (630 AD)

Muhammad’s army of 10,000 marched on Mecca, facing little resistance.
The city was taken without a major battle, and the idols in the Kaaba were destroyed.
Non-Muslims were given the choice to convert, pay the jizya (tax), or face death.

4. Why This Three-Stage Strategy Still Matters Today

The three stages of Islam are not just history — they are a strategic model for Islamic expansion.
Even in the modern world, Islamic movements use the same approach:
- Stage One: Present Islam as peaceful.
- Stage Two: Build a strong, organized community.
- Stage Three: Assert political and legal influence, pushing for Sharia.

Modern Examples: The Three Stages in Action

United Kingdom: From peaceful coexistence to demands for Sharia-compliant schools.
France: From interfaith dialogue to pressure for Islamic prayer spaces.
Canada: From tolerance to the push for Sharia family law.

Conclusion: One Religion, Three Faces

Islam is not just one thing — it is a flexible, adaptable belief system that changes its message depending on its situation. Understanding the Three Faces of Islam is critical for anyone who wants to understand the true nature of the faith and its impact on society.

If Islam is truly a religion of peace, why does it become aggressive when it gains power?
If the Quran is the clear and final word of God, why does it teach peace in one place and violence in another?

The answer lies in the strategy of the three stages — a strategy that has been used since Muhammad’s time and continues to this day.

The Two Faces of Islam: Peace for the Public, Power Behind Closed Doors
The Thin Edge of the Wedge: How Gradualism is Changing New Zealand
The Push for an Islamic State: How the Dream of Sharia is Pursued Worldwide

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

About the Author

Mauao Man is a blog created by a New Zealand writer who believes in following the evidence wherever it leads. From history and religion to culture and society, Mauao Man takes a clear, critical, and honest approach — challenging ideas without attacking people. Whether exploring the history of Islam in New Zealand, the complexities of faith, or the contradictions in belief systems, this blog is about asking the hard questions and uncovering the truth.

If you value clarity over comfort and truth over tradition, you’re in the right place.