10 Myths About Islam That Don’t Survive Scrutiny

Myth 1: "Islam Is a Religion of Peace."

The Reality:

Islam contains teachings of both peace and conflict, depending on the context. The Quran includes verses that promote peaceful coexistence (Quran 5:32), but it also includes verses that call for violence against unbelievers (Quran 9:5, 9:29). Islamic history reflects this duality — peaceful periods of coexistence alongside periods of conquest and warfare.

• Historical Evidence: The early Islamic caliphates expanded through both peaceful trade and military conquest, from the Middle East to North Africa, Europe, and Asia.

• Logical Problem: A belief system cannot be defined by its most comfortable passages alone. To understand Islam, one must look at the full range of its teachings.

---

Myth 2: "Islam Is Just Like Christianity and Judaism."

The Reality:

While Islam claims to share a heritage with Christianity and Judaism, it fundamentally reinterprets their stories, teachings, and figures:

• Jesus (Isa) in Islam is not the divine Son of God but a human prophet who denies his own divinity (Quran 4:171).

• The Bible is considered corrupted in Islamic theology, with the Quran presented as the final, unaltered revelation — even though historical evidence shows that the Bible has been remarkably well-preserved.

• Salvation in Islam is based on works and submission to Allah, not on grace or faith as in Christianity.

---

Myth 3: "The Quran Has Been Perfectly Preserved."

The Reality:

The claim of perfect preservation is a central belief in Islam, but historical evidence contradicts it:

• Manuscript Variants: Early Quranic manuscripts, such as the Sanaa Manuscripts, show textual variations, corrections, and missing passages.

• The Uthmanic Standardization: Caliph Uthman ordered the burning of all other Quranic versions to create a single standard version. This action directly contradicts the claim of perfect preservation.

• Hadith Evidence: Even Islamic sources mention that verses were lost, abrogated, or forgotten (Sahih Muslim 2286, Sahih Bukhari 503).

---

Myth 4: "Sharia Law Is Just a Personal Code of Conduct."

The Reality:

Sharia is a comprehensive legal system that covers personal conduct, family law, criminal law, and governance:

• Legal Enforcement: In Islamic history, Sharia was enforced as state law, with punishments for theft (amputation), adultery (stoning), and apostasy (death).

• Modern Context: While many Muslims interpret Sharia as a personal code, its historical application has always been as a system of religious law for society.

---

Myth 5: "Islam Respects All Religions."

The Reality:

While the Quran speaks of "People of the Book" (Jews and Christians) with a degree of respect, it also contains verses that call for fighting them (Quran 9:29) or subjecting them to dhimmi status — a form of second-class citizenship.

• Dhimmi System: In Islamic history, non-Muslims in Muslim-ruled lands were often subject to the jizya tax and were restricted in their rights.

• Religious Supremacy: The Quran presents Islam as the final and superior revelation, rejecting the core beliefs of other faiths (Quran 3:85).

---

Myth 6: "Jihad Only Means a Personal Struggle."

The Reality:

Jihad has multiple meanings in Islamic theology:

• Greater Jihad: The personal, spiritual struggle to be a better Muslim.

• Lesser Jihad: Armed struggle in the name of Islam, which has historically included both defensive and offensive warfare.

• Historical Context: From the early Islamic conquests to the Ottoman expansions, jihad has been used to justify military campaigns.

---

Myth 7: "Islam Is Compatible with Western Values."

The Reality:

Traditional Islamic teachings conflict with many Western values:

• Freedom of Speech: Criticism of Islam is often considered blasphemy (Quran 33:57).

• Gender Equality: Sharia assigns women half the inheritance of men (Quran 4:11), and their testimony is worth half that of a man (Quran 2:282).

• Religious Freedom: Apostasy is punishable by death in traditional Islamic law.

---

Myth 8: "The Prophets of Islam Are the Same as in the Bible."

The Reality:

Islamic theology redefines biblical figures:

• Jesus (Isa) is a prophet who denies his divinity and is not crucified.

• Abraham (Ibrahim) is redefined, with the son of sacrifice being Ishmael, not Isaac.

• Moses (Musa) is given a narrative that differs significantly from the biblical account.

---

Myth 9: "Islam’s Growth Is Always Peaceful."

The Reality:

Islam’s growth has been a mix of peaceful trade, missionary work, and military conquest.

• Historical Evidence: The early caliphates expanded through military campaigns.

• Modern Spread: Islam also spread through trade and migration, but historical records show that forced conversions were part of some Islamic empires.

---

Myth 10: "Islam is Just a Religion — It’s Not Political."

The Reality:

Islam is both a religion and a complete socio-political system:

• Sharia Law: Covers criminal, family, financial, and international law.

• The Caliphate: A historical Islamic state ruled by religious leaders who enforced Sharia.

• Modern Implications: Islamist groups continue to advocate for political Islam.

---

Conclusion: Questioning Ideas, Not Attacking People

Ideas are not sacred — but people are. This post is about questioning an ideology, not attacking individuals. Islam, like any belief system, makes claims about the world, and those claims deserve to be examined critically.

Everything you have read here is drawn directly from Islam’s own sources — the Quran, Hadith, and Islamic history. If an idea is true, it can stand up to scrutiny. If it collapses under honest questions, it should not be hidden behind myths.

In a world where misinformation is everywhere, clarity is not just a luxury — it is a necessity.

Related Posts:

• Islam Isn’t What Muslims Say — It’s What the Quran Says

• The Blind Spot: What Most Kiwis Don’t Know About Islam

• Islam: What It Really Teaches — And What It Means for New Zealand

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

About the Author

Mauao Man is a blog created by a New Zealand writer who believes in following the evidence wherever it leads. From history and religion to culture and society, Mauao Man takes a clear, critical, and honest approach — challenging ideas without attacking people. Whether exploring the history of Islam in New Zealand, the complexities of faith, or the contradictions in belief systems, this blog is about asking the hard questions and uncovering the truth.

If you value clarity over comfort and truth over tradition, you’re in the right place.